Photo of Corey Cohen

Why domestic violence claims can cause trouble after recantation

False allegations of domestic violence may occur due to reasons such as financial gain, sympathy seeking, pressure from others or revenge, among other reasons. These falsehoods can lead to severe consequences.

Unfortunately, recanting does not mean the accused’s life returns to where it was before the allegations.

The perceived credibility of recantations

People do not always see recantations as credible. Individuals may doubt the sincerity of the recantation, suspecting the involvement of coercion or threats. This skepticism can lead to continued legal and social consequences for the accused.

Legal issues

Even after a recantation, prosecutors may decide to pursue the case based on the available evidence, including medical records, eyewitness accounts and prior allegations or incidents. This can lead to immense trouble for people falsely accused. In Orange County, domestic violence offenses are more common at 393.8 per 100,000 population than in Florida as a whole (305 offenses per 100,000 population). Some of these offenses involve false accusations, whether recanted or not.

Lingering stigma

The stigma associated with domestic violence allegations can persist long after recantation. Friends, family and community members may continue to view the accused as a potential threat, leading to strained relationships and social isolation.

Employers and educational institutions may also consider such allegations during background checks, potentially affecting a person’s career or academic opportunities. People can lose their jobs and not necessarily get them back after a recantation.

Ongoing trauma

It is not always easy to get over the harm a false accusation does. For example, people wrongly accused of domestic violence can experience strained relationships with their children or even a loss of custody. Conditions such as high blood pressure, sleep disturbances and other stress-related health problems may develop or worsen. Fired employees may struggle to find other work.

Domestic violence allegations can continue to cause trouble even after a recantation due to the complex and deeply ingrained nature of the issue. To address the trauma and move forward, some individuals seek therapy or counseling.



FindLaw Network